Research Guide for ENG388W: Planetary Futures

Here are a few things to look out for when evaluating the reliability of a source.

• Consider who published and wrote the work. While scholarship published by a trade press does not mean it is “bad”, some presses and journals publish higher quality work than others.
• As you assess a source, note how the author is citing their work. In periodicals, does the author reference any interviews or sources?  Is it well cited with footnotes or in-text citations?Or is there simply a list of sources in the back of the book? Note the language that the author is using, and/or the work the text is citing. Does it align with how other scholars talk about that topic or field?
• Academic publishers sometimes publish essay collections that are not peer reviewed. This does not mean that they aren’t edited or assessed by other scholars, but sometimes these collections are not as rigorously vetted as a peer reviewed journals.

An excellent guide from the Emory Libraries Reference Desk

1. What is it about? The title will be your first immediate clue. Read the abstract (a summary of the article) to know if an article is related to the topic you're researching. No abstract? Read the introduction of the article and scan the article headings.

2. What is the subject area focus? Knowing what discipline an article comes from can help you decide if the article is relevant. Look at the title of the book/article or the journal title to try to determine the subject area. Researching climate change activism for a political science class? An article on climate change from a chemistry journal may be too technical and not focused on political issues.

3. Will it help you answer your research question?

4. Are you looking for recent information? If so, the publication date will be a critical clue to whether the article or book is relevant.

5. Ask yourself how you might use the source -- will you be analyzing it, using it for background/factual information, arguing for or against the same point it's making, etc.?

6. Is it a book, book chapter, or an article? If your professor only wants you to use a specific type of information like peer-reviewed journal articles, it is important to know that.

7. Is it scholarly? If you are required to use only scholarly sources, you will need to figure out whether the item is scholarly or not.

• For books, look at the publisher (is it a university press or other scholarly press? You may need to look up the publisher to figure it out).
• For articles, look at the title of the journal (not the article title). You can search for the journal title in Ulrichs International Periodicals Directory to determine whether the journal is scholarly/refereed. Note that some databases will indicate in the results whether the article is scholarly or not, and in some databases, you can limit your search to just scholarly articles.

8. What type of article is it? Not every article in a journal -- even in a scholarly journal -- may be appropriate for your research. In addition to research articles and feature articles, peer-reviewed journals contain book reviews, editorials, interviews, and more. The type of article may be apparent from the information provided by the database, but in some cases, you may need to read the abstract or even the beginning of the article before you know for sure. When in doubt about whether something is appropriate, look at your assignment instructions and/or ask your instructor.

9. If it is a research study, what type is it? This may only be relevant in courses that require a specific type of research be used (quantitative, qualitative, experimental, systematic review, etc.). The abstract usually contains clues about the type of study. Also, look in the article for a "Methods" section, which should describe how the research was conducted. If one does not exist, it's probably not a research study.