Systematic and scoping reviews answer very specific research questions. Using a question framework, like PICO or PEO, helps you to organize your research topic into an answerable question. Keep in mind that these frameworks are just a tool, not a science!
PICO | PEO |
P: Population I: Intervention C: Comparison/control O: Outcome |
P: Population E: Exposure O: Outcome |
P: East Africa I: Access to water C: none O: Food insecurity |
P: Deaf and hard of hearing teenagers E: Sexual education classes O: Individuals' experiences |
How does access to water impact food insecurity for the population of East Africa? | What are the sexual education experiences of Deaf and hard of hearing teenagers? |
PICO and PEO aren't the only question frameworks that exist; you may find that your question fits better into a SPIDER, SPICE, or ECLIPSE format, or something else.
SPIDER | SPICE | ECLIPSE |
S: Sample P/I: Phenomenon of Interest D: Design E: Evaluation R: Research type |
S: Setting P: Perspective I: Intervention or Interest C: Comparison E: Evaluation |
E: Expectation C: Client group L: Location I: Impact P: Professionals S: Service |
Systematic Review | Scoping Review |
---|---|
How effective is rifampin in the treatment of drug-resistant tuberculosis? | What programs exist to curb the spread of drug-resistant tuberculosis? |
What are the experiences of parents in the United States regarding childhood seasonal flu vaccination? | How are the experiences of parents in the United States regarding childhood seasonal flu vaccines being studied? |
In assisted living facilities, do therapy dog visits reduce feelings of loneliness in residents? | What are the clinical applications of therapy dog visits in healthcare settings? |
What are the effects of handwashing on the reduction of the spread of e. coli in Zambia? | What water sanitation practices are being used in Zambia? |